Pinui Binui 2026: Who Finances the Project Matters More Than Extra Meters

On November 3 it was reported that the Tel Aviv District Court ordered four apartment owners in Givatayim to sign a pinui binui (urban renewal by demolition and reconstruction) agreement within 30 days. In the days before, reports said demolition had begun on HaAmoraim Street in Neve Avivim, about a decade after the project first got under way, and a Jerusalem construction company that had built an urban renewal project of 226 apartments entered insolvency proceedings with the building roughly 80% complete. In our view the lesson of this week is clear: in pinui binui in 2026, an apartment owner should first ask who will finance and build the project, and only then how many square meters they will receive. An extra ten square meters that arrives three years late is worth less than a smaller addition that arrives on time.

In pinui binui, an apartment owner’s bargaining power lies in the choice of developer and in the guarantees, not in refusing at the end of the road. By our calculation, a delay of about two and a half years is enough to wipe out the advantage of ten additional square meters in the new apartment.

  • In Givatayim, four apartment owners who claimed damage of about half a million shekels per apartment were ordered to sign and to pay ₪40,000 in costs.
  • The Bank of Israel reported that in the third quarter the banks tightened credit terms for construction and real estate companies.
  • For a new apartment of 95 sqm versus 85 sqm, at ₪55,000 per sqm, the difference is ₪550,000, and a three year delay turns it into a loss.
  • On HaAmoraim Street in Neve Avivim, owners in one project receive 25 sqm and owners in a neighboring project receive 15 sqm, and both numbers are correct.

What moved in pinui binui and urban renewal this week

Refusing at the end of the road is losing its force. In a 32 apartment building from 1974 on HaMaavak Street in Givatayim, 28 apartment owners had already signed in January 2022. Four refused, arguing that the agreement calculated their apartments at 60 sqm when in fact they measure about 68 sqm. According to the report on ynet, the court rejected the claim, ordered them to sign within 30 days and to pay ₪40,000 in costs. Since the 2021 amendment to the law, the majority required to sue an owner who refuses unreasonably is 66% in the compound and 60% in each building. What this means for an apartment owner: anyone who wants better terms has to negotiate them before the majority signs, not after.

A decade until the bulldozer. At 11 to 13 HaAmoraim Street in Neve Avivim, Bayit VeGag has begun work: two four storey buildings from the 1970s, with 28 apartments, will make way for two eight storey buildings with 68 apartments. The apartment owners receive an addition of 25 sqm. According to the report, the average price in the project is about ₪55,000 per sqm, and the project was in the works for about ten years before demolition began.

Plans are plentiful. On October 29 12 new pinui binui compounds were declared, six of them in Tel Aviv, in which 896 existing apartments will be replaced by 2,355 apartments. In Herzliya the Ben Gurion compound was declared, 371 apartments that will become 1,339. A day earlier the plan for Districts 5 and 6 was approved, with about 14,000 additional housing units in the city center. And on November 4 a plan was approved for deposit in Hod HaSharon on Ben Gurion Street in the Ramatayim neighborhood, 80 apartments to be replaced by 202. Yet according to the annual report of the Government Authority for Urban Renewal, permits were issued in 2025 for 13,066 apartments in pinui binui, a decline of 15% compared with 2024, even though plans for about 76,000 apartments were approved that same year. In other words, planning is no longer the bottleneck.

Money is becoming more cautious. In the Bank of Israel survey of bank officers for the third quarter, published on October 22, the banks reported tighter credit terms for construction and real estate companies and expect demand for credit to keep declining. On October 28 the Jerusalem District Court ordered the opening of insolvency proceedings against a construction company with debts of about ₪100 million. Work on the urban renewal project it was building, 226 apartments in five buildings, stopped when construction had reached about 80%, and the project company replaced the contractor.

The thesis: in pinui binui, time is worth more than meters

The debate among apartment owners before signing almost always centers on one number: how many square meters are added. The policy approved by the Tel Aviv planning and building committee in 2019 set an addition of 12 sqm for each existing apartment and a minimum of 60 sqm for the new apartment, and the Government Authority for Urban Renewal speaks of 12 sqm and a balcony, usually with parking and a storage room. In practice, as HaAmoraim Street shows, the consideration varies from project to project.

But that number is only worth something if the new apartment actually arrives, and arrives on time. According to a study by the Knesset Research and Information Center, a pinui binui project takes 10 to 15 years from start to finish. In June 2026 the State Comptroller cited the Brandeis compound in Ra’anana, where about 23 years passed from start to occupancy. And in December 2025 the Chief Government Appraiser raised the minimum developer profit in pinui binui in the Tel Aviv district from 14% to 16%, within a range of 15% to 17%. When the bar for feasibility rises and credit tightens, a project signed on especially generous terms is a project with less margin for error. That is why, in our view, a developer with financial backing and closed bank financing is worth more to the apartment owner than a few additional meters on paper.

The math: ten square meters versus three years

Assume, purely for illustration, the owner of a 70 sqm apartment in a 1970s building in Neve Avivim who receives two offers. Offer A: an addition of 25 sqm, a new apartment of 95 sqm, from a developer that has not yet closed bank financing. Offer B: an addition of 15 sqm, an apartment of 85 sqm, from a developer with financing in place. Our assumptions, all of them stated:

  • Value of the new apartment: ₪55,000 per sqm, the average price reported for the project on HaAmoraim Street. The price stays constant over time.
  • Rent during construction is paid by the developer under both offers, and the construction period is identical. The only difference is the delivery date.
  • Discount rate: 4.35% a year, the weighted average nominal mortgage interest rate in September according to Bank of Israel data. This is an estimate of the price of money, not a forecast.
Delay of Offer A relative to Offer B Present value of the apartment in Offer A Advantage over Offer B (₪4,675,000)
No delay ₪5,225,000 ₪550,000
One year ₪5,007,187 ₪332,187
Two years ₪4,798,455 ₪123,455
Three years ₪4,598,423 Loss of ₪76,577
Four years ₪4,406,730 Loss of ₪268,270

The break even point comes out at about 2.6 years. Ten square meters are about 11.8% of the apartment in Offer B, and that sounds like a lot. But in a field where projects run a decade and more, a three year delay is not an extreme scenario.

And the table ignores the heavier risk: a project that stops halfway. That is why the clauses that are truly worth money are the guarantees. A Sale Law guarantee for the value of the new apartment, valid until delivery. An autonomous rent guarantee, which can be called without legal proceedings. And a tax guarantee, in case the exemptions do not apply. In the Jerusalem project the contractor was replaced, and the trustee must submit by November 29 an initial opinion on the company’s prospects of rehabilitation. On September 8 the Supreme Court rejected a request by 86 apartment owners in Neve Chen in Tel Aviv to cancel an agreement because of the developer’s collapse, and ruled that the decision belongs in the insolvency proceedings. In other words, canceling the agreement is not an exit button, and the guarantees are the main protection.

Refusal is no longer a bargaining chip

In Givatayim, the dispute ran almost three years from the majority’s signing until the lawsuit was filed in November 2024, and another two years until the ruling. The refusing owners did not get what they demanded, and they paid costs. Meanwhile the entire building waited.

The law defines when a refusal is reasonable: when the transaction is not economically viable, when no alternative housing was offered, when sufficient guarantees were not provided, or in special personal circumstances. Note the third ground. Refusing because of weak guarantees is an argument the courts recognize. Refusing over additional meters is much harder to justify. That is why, in our view, an apartment owner who has a claim should raise it at the stage when the residents choose a developer and a lawyer, and write it into the agreement, with an appraiser and a lawyer representing the residents. A full explanation of the tracks, the required majority and the choice of developer can be found in our urban renewal guide.

Who this matters to, and how

  • An apartment owner in an older building: the first questions are which bank or financing body is involved, whether there is a commitment to project financing, and which guarantees will be provided before the evacuation. The consideration comes after that. And also: the exit dates in the agreement. Under the 2021 amendment, a majority in the building can cancel the transaction if 50% have not signed within two years of the first signature, or 60% have not signed within four years.
  • A seller of an apartment in such a building: the planning stage determines the price. A buyer will pay for a signed agreement with a strong developer and for an approved plan, not for a promise. Before setting a price, it is worth getting a property valuation that takes this stage into account.
  • A buyer trading up: an older apartment in a building facing pinui binui can be a good way into a neighborhood, but you need to check the documents, not the headlines. What to check before buying is set out in our guide to buying an apartment in a renewal project in Ramat Aviv.
  • An investor: the calculation above applies several times over. Their capital is tied up for the entire project, and the exemptions from capital gains tax (mas shevach) and purchase tax (mas rechisha) in pinui binui apply to the replacement apartment under the conditions and ceilings set by law. Every transaction needs a review by a tax advisor.
  • The luxury market: at the top end, the new apartments being built through urban renewal are already selling. On November 1 a penthouse on Brodetsky Street in Ramat Aviv HaYeruka was reported sold for ₪10.8 million, 141 sqm plus 88 sqm of balconies, according to the developer’s report. Anyone selling a large older apartment in the area is competing with them.

A look at Neve Avivim: same street, two kinds of consideration

Neve Avivim may be the best laboratory in north Tel Aviv for understanding pinui binui. According to Madlan data published in August, about 27 developers are active in the neighborhood with about 3,673 housing units under construction and in planning. The neighborhood currently has about 5,264 apartments.

On HaAmoraim Street itself, at buildings 6, 8 and 10, Tzemach Hammerman won a residents’ tender in 2024: 76 apartments in six and seven storey buildings will be replaced by 172 apartments, with an addition of 15 sqm for the apartment owners. On the same street, at buildings 11 to 13, owners receive 25 sqm. The difference is no accident: low four storey buildings have more building rights to share per existing apartment. In other words, the consideration is determined mainly by the building and the plan, not by the owners’ negotiating skills.

At 5 to 9 Hofien Street a project of 72 apartments that will become 134 is moving forward, and according to the July report financing of about ₪750 million from Bank Jerusalem and an insurance company was signed for it. At 7, 11 and 13 HaSavoraim Street, 107 apartments are being built in place of 42. By contrast, at 14 to 22 Yehuda HaNasi Street a plan was approved in 2023, 80 apartments that will become 195, and it is still in planning.

And what is happening to prices in the meantime? According to the same Madlan data, in the first half of 2026 the number of transactions in the neighborhood fell by about 37% compared with the same period a year earlier, while the price per apartment rose by about 1.4%. According to a July report in Bizportal, transactions recorded in the neighborhood ranged from about ₪42,500 to about ₪52,800 per sqm, and the average price reported for the new project on HaAmoraim Street is about ₪55,000 per sqm. That gap is exactly what the owner of an older apartment needs to examine. More on the neighborhood on our Neve Avivim page and in the guide buying an apartment in Neve Avivim.

What we still do not know

  • There is no official figure for the average time from signing a pinui binui agreement to occupancy, and no official count of projects that have stalled. The numbers we have are Knesset estimates and State Comptroller examples.
  • Whether the decline in permits in 2025 marks the start of a trend. The Authority’s 2026 data have not yet been published.
  • Plan TA/5555, which is meant to replace tama 38 (TAMA 38, the national seismic reinforcement and renewal plan) in Tel Aviv, was deposited in 2025 and has not yet received final approval.
  • How many developers will seek to reopen agreements signed in 2021 and 2022, when costs and interest rates were different. Reports of such requests have already been published this year.

In the coming weeks it is worth following the Bank of Israel interest rate decision on November 23, the Central Bureau of Statistics home price index, which is usually published in the middle of the month, and the quarterly reports of the real estate companies, which show which developer is closing project financing and which is not.

Frequently Asked Questions

What majority is needed to sue a refusing owner in pinui binui

Since the 2021 amendment to the law, 66% of the apartment owners in the compound and 60% in each building. The majority can sue an owner who refuses unreasonably. Every case should be reviewed by a lawyer.

When is a refusal of pinui binui considered reasonable

Under the law and the guidelines of the Authority for Urban Renewal, among other cases when the transaction is not economically viable, when no alternative housing was offered, when sufficient guarantees were not provided, or in special personal circumstances such as old age or disability.

Which guarantees should an apartment owner receive in pinui binui

Usually a Sale Law guarantee for the value of the new apartment, a guarantee for the payment of rent, and a tax guarantee in case the exemptions do not apply. They are provided by the financing body before the evacuation, and the residents’ lawyer reviews their wording.

How many square meters are added in pinui binui in Tel Aviv

The policy approved by the municipality in 2019 set an addition of 12 sqm and a new apartment of at least 60 sqm, and a balcony is not counted in the addition. In practice the consideration varies by building and plan. On HaAmoraim Street in Neve Avivim there is one project with 25 sqm and a neighboring project with 15 sqm.

Is there capital gains tax in pinui binui

In pinui binui within a declared compound, apartment owners are exempt from capital gains tax (mas shevach) and purchase tax (mas rechisha) on the replacement apartment, up to the ceilings set by law. A tax advisor should review each case on its merits.

In Summary

In pinui binui, signing is the moment when the apartment owner determines what they will receive and when. RS Nadlan accompanies clients in Tel Aviv, Ramat HaSharon, Herzliya, Ra’anana and Kfar Saba, with a specialization in the neighborhoods of north Tel Aviv, and a short conversation is enough to examine what a specific apartment is worth at each stage of the project. Leave your details or call 077-500-4600 (+972 77 500 4600). Meetings at our offices in Ramat Aviv Gimel are scheduled by prior appointment. Nothing in this review constitutes legal or tax advice.

Our properties for sale in Neve Avivim

Picture of RS Nadlan

RS Nadlan

RS Nadlan is a real estate marketing and brokerage company operating in north Tel Aviv, Ramat HaSharon, Herzliya, Ra’anana and Kfar Saba. The company guides property owners, buyers and investors in residential and luxury transactions, combining in depth neighborhood knowledge, professional marketing and precise deal management.
Table of Contents
Connecting quality properties with serious buyers
We specialize in a high quality clientele and precision deals. Leave your details, and we will determine if your property (or the one you are looking for) matches our active portfolio.

Your inquiry has been received

An RS Nadlan representative will contact you about your inquiry. We have also sent a confirmation to the email address you entered.